Reader Question:
I recently retired, and, over my career, I accumulated a significant amount of company stock. Should I sell or hold onto it?
Answer:
Hi Jeff, thank you for the question. To give a formal recommendation, it’s helpful to know more about your specific situation, but I can provide you with some strategies on how to handle the shares depending on what type of account they are in.
First, if these shares happen to be in your 401(k), you have a few different options. Since we do not pay capital gains taxes on retirement accounts, you can rebalance the account at any point. Depending on the company or the percentage you own in the account, you could sell a small portion or a large amount. This will depend on the risk you are willing to take and the outlook for the company you received the shares from. The second option is a little more unique and very helpful for long-term planning. This is called Net Realized Appreciation or NUA. With this approach, you can move all of the shares from a retirement account to a brokerage account and only pay taxes on the original purchase price. This will make the most sense for shares that have appreciated significantly. The long-term benefit is that these funds will no longer be forced to be taken out of the accounts when you turn 73 or 75 for required distributions. An analysis should be run to measure the short-term taxes paid this year versus the long-term tax savings to ensure this is the right decision for you.
If the funds are in a taxable account, you will want to be more tactical as you will need to pay capital gains taxes on the increase in the value since purchase. If your goal is to liquidate a portion, you can look to see which purchases have the highest cost basis and sell those shares for a smaller gain or even a loss. Depending on your income each year, you may also be exempt from capital gains taxes. If you file taxes jointly with a spouse and your taxable income is under $98,900, you are not required to pay capital gains taxes. This is after deductions so if you are married filing jointly, your gross income can be $130,000 without paying capital gains taxes and for single filers it can be up to $65,000 (sometimes even higher). You may want to liquidate a large portion of the shares if the stock represents a significant portion of your portfolio, but you will want to be careful depending on the size. If the capital gains are substantial, your income may rise above the Medicare IRMAA premium levels, which can increase your monthly Medicare premiums significantly. These limits are published by the IRS and can easily be found by googling the calendar year and IRMAA table.
If you are looking to reduce your taxes for the current year, you could also donate some of your shares to charity. You can give the shares directly to a charity of your choice, or you could contribute to a donor-advised fund. With the donor-advised fund, you donate shares and then have the ability to direct your donations to several charities over several years, giving you more control of your charitable donations.
Regardless of where the stock is held, you will want to create a long-term strategy that will incorporate not just investments but also taxes, as these two areas work hand in hand with each other. Working with the right team could not only produce significant long-term growth but also significant long-term tax savings for you and your family.
John McGowan, CFA, MBA, of Carson Wealth will answer select reader-submitted questions and offer professional insights on investing, retirement planning, estate planning, taxes and other personal finance topics.
Have a financial question you’d like addressed in a future column? Email your question to Pittsburgh@carsonwealth.com. Selected questions may be featured in an upcoming edition.



